The Council of Learned Journals has given its "Best Journal Design Award" to
The Southern Review.
The full-page acknowledgment of the award, in the Spring issue, quotes the award's citation: "a comforting sense of literary materiality... This is a design for people who love the tactile and palpable aspects of literature."
In general, I agree: the texts feel good on the page.
(What's the diff between "tactile" and "palpable"? If they really want palpable, they should use letterpress, an extravagant tactic last tried in a litmag, I think, by Ben Sonnenberg, when he was trying to squander his inheritance with the original
Grand Street in the eighties. I've recommended it to
Poetry.)The look is classically restrained; the layout is simple-- no pull-quotes, no blocks of color behind texts, no sidebars, no colored rules....which is more than we can say for the award's runner-up,
VQR, aka,
The Virginia Quarterly Review, which is a splendid example of two much money chasing too much inspiration.
The page size is very big for a journal, 6 3/4 x 10 inches, and there are 256 of them, numbered from the beginning of the year, hence, this first text in this issue, the second of the year, starts on page 253. (Isn't that learned!)
The margins are generous, although the footers (the page numbers at the bottom) are annoyingly indented and, to my eye, too close to the text, and the headers at the top of each left-hand page repeat the name of the journal, as if we might have forgotten. I find it particularly obnoxious when
the name of the journal appears, in small caps, above the title of a poem.
The 36 pages of reviews at the back of the book are announced by a "title page," followed by a blank, a pseudo-elegant waste of space and a pathetic act of segregation. The "In Brief" reviews are set smaller than the main texts, a common learned practice, but one that strikes me as patronizing (they are not worth standard-sized), rather than economical (more words can be squeezed in).
On the cover, on the spine, on the title page, on the contents, and in an ad, the "the" of
the Southern Review is lower cased, but on the copyright page and on the inside back cover (the donors' page), the
The is capped.
The cover bleeds a b&w photo, and the same photo, in a half-sized detail, is used on the back cover, which is filled to the edge (bled) with an appropriate shade of gray, while below the photo are the names of the contributors.
The subtitle on the front cover reads, in small caps, PUBLISHED QUARTERLY AT LOUISIANA STATE UNIVERSITY, which, although inelegant, presumably helps convince the administration that the journal's budget is justified as public relations.
The inside front cover states: "No unsolicited manuscripts will be read/during June, July, and August." To which the proper response is, I think: Excuse MEEE."
The bio blurbs are offered just after the contents, which is better than hiding them in the back of the book, although the title "Contributors" is weirdly indented.
Eight photographs (and the cover) by Neil Folberg
(who appeared in ZYZZYVA Spring '87), from a book forthcoming this fall, comprise the "art portfolio," presented on coated stock, preceded by another "title" page, which should at least have contained more of Folberg's "author," Lin Arison's "statement"--she is given only a paragraph excerpted from the book on the "blank" following page. The selection of images seems skimpy and perfunctory.The color ones seem murky to me.
Sometimes, when a poem starts on a right-hand page, the poet's name is incorporated into the header, at other times, the poet's name is flush left, just above the title. This inconsistency is disturbing.
Did I mention the spine, which reads:
Volume
43
Number
2
Spring
2007
although, to be fair, I should state that those words and numbers are centered. As they are, at the bottom of this ugly (white) spine:
Louisiana
State
University
At the bottom of the full-page announcement of the Award:
With gratitude and admiration the Editors recognize
the high degree to which this award reflects the talent and
meticulous care of this journal's designer and typesetter
BARBARA NEELY BOURGOYNE